In a historic and symbolic move, former President Donald Trump appointed Alice Marie Johnson, the first Black woman to serve as a federal clemency advisor, his official “Pardon Czar.” Johnson, a criminal justice reform advocate who was granted clemency by Trump in 2018 after serving over two decades for a nonviolent drug offense, now leads the charge in reviewing clemency requests and advising on one of the most powerful tools of the presidency: the pardon.
Her appointment stands as a milestone for criminal justice reform and representation at the highest levels of executive decision-making. It reflects Trump’s ongoing effort to frame clemency as both a matter of justice and political will, particularly in cases involving long, controversial sentences handed down to Black Americans.
This broader shift in approach set the stage for two of the most attention-grabbing clemency decisions in Trump’s second term: the full pardon of rap artist NBA YoungBoy and the commutation of federal sentences for Chicago gang figure Larry Hoover.
NBA YoungBoy: A Pardon and a Clean Slate
Kentrell DeSean Gaulden, better known as NBA YoungBoy, was serving a 23-month sentence for federal gun charges stemming from arrests in Louisiana and California. Though released to house arrest earlier this year, he still faced prescription fraud charges and remained under legal scrutiny.
Trump’s pardon wiped Gaulden’s record clean and restored his ability to tour and travel freely. The rapper issued a public statement following the announcement:
“I want to thank President Trump for granting me a pardon and allowing me to keep building — as a man, father, and artist.”
YoungBoy is set to launch a national tour in fall 2025, marking a significant turnaround in his career and public image.
Larry Hoover: A Partial Win in a Long Fight
While NBA YoungBoy walks free, Larry Hoover’s story is more complicated. Once the leader of the Gangster Disciples, Hoover has been in prison since the 1970s, serving both a 200-year state sentence for murder and six federal life sentences for continuing to operate a criminal enterprise from behind bars.
Trump’s commutation only affected federal convictions, meaning that Hoover will remain in Illinois state custody in the foreseeable future. Nonetheless, his legal team views the move as critical to achieving his release.
Hoover’s case has long drawn the attention of celebrities like Kanye West and Drake, who co-headlined a 2021 benefit concert titled “Free Larry Hoover.” The commutation offers renewed hope to his supporters while reigniting debate over whether clemency should extend to individuals with violent pasts who claim rehabilitation.
Reform or Strategy?
By combining Alice Johnson’s historic appointment with these high-profile clemency decisions, Trump has returned the conversation around redemption, justice, and political power to the national spotlight. Supporters see a genuine effort to reform a broken and biased justice system. Critics argue that it’s a calculated move aimed at strengthening Trump’s image among Black voters and in pop culture.
A Growing Divide in Black Politics
Perhaps most revealing is how these actions are reshaping Trump’s image within Black communities. While many establishment Black leaders and elected officials continue to paint Trump as a threat to civil rights and democracy, a growing number of everyday Black Americans, particularly younger generations, are rethinking that narrative.
For some, it’s not about personality but policy and outcomes. They see Trump doing things that decades of Democratic leadership failed to deliver: pushing economic opportunity zones, highlighting criminal justice reform, and now, issuing clemency to Black Americans caught in a system long viewed as unjust. The shift isn’t uniform, but it’s enough to spark conversations—and concern—among traditional Black political circles.
As one observer put it, “Trump may not be the Black community’s choice—but he’s increasingly becoming their challenge to the status quo.”
Bottom Line: With the appointment of Alice Marie Johnson, the pardons of NBA YoungBoy and Larry Hoover, and the growing split in how Trump is viewed across the Black political spectrum, it’s clear that the conversation is changing. Whether seen as justice or strategy, Donald Trump is forcing Black America to reexamine power, not just who holds it, but how they use it.
2 Comments
For me and I am just speaking for myself, a greater example of redefining Criminal Justice Politics would have been to pardon Assata Olugbala Shakur (Joanne Chesimard) and/or political activist and journalist Mumia Abu-Jamal (born Wesley Cook), that would be the very definition of redefining Criminal Justice Politics not pardoning a rapper convicted on federal gun charges and the commutation of federal convictions of a celebrated notorious gangster. No disrespect to either individual, but what are we talking about here? Pardoning Black political activists who highlight the ongoing struggle for civil rights and the challenges faced by those who advocate for social justice, particularly within the context of racial injustice and systemic biases, would show me he wants to redefine Criminal Justice Politics. I’m happy to see a sister as a federal clemency advisor, “Pardon Czar.” I only hope that she will use the position to advocate for the many truly deserving political prisoners who fought for social justice and spoke up against racial injustice and systemic biases. I do not expect everyone to agree with me, but I had to share my opinion. Until proven otherwise, this is just another example of symbolism without substance.
This is the comment I was looking for. Thank you.